My recent success with my choral arrangement piece “If Thou Wilt, Remember” has inspired me and given me the confidence to go back and take a look at some of my earlier compositions and restart the writing process.
I’ve been writing little pieces since I was 10. I have an entire computer file full of ideas in various states of completeness. Some works have been reasonably finished. I’ve even had a couple performed by my old church youth ensemble, but most are bear skeletons of pieces or even just a few lines. So many more don’t even exist in any type of written form but only as part of great long fantasias of noodle-ing I routinely play on the piano.
For those of you who may not be familiar with the ever so technical term, noodle-ing is a form of improvised composition. Rather like dancing alone in your room to classic 80’s pop with the blinds closed, there are no rules, no goals, you simply play and mess around like no one’s watching. It usually only sounds good to the person playing and tends to just irritate everyone else.
I think I’ve mentioned before how noodle-ing is the musical activity that I do to take a break from my music work. Whenever I’m in a practice room I always end up spending some time noodle-ing. It’s a stress reliever. It’s one way for me to really sink my hands into music and let myself get lost. Because the piano is not my “instrument” and I’m not a trained composer, when I “noodle” around and play, I feel free. I don’t worry about technique or style. I don’t worry about what I sound like or whether I’m doing it right not. I don’t care what other people might think about it. I simply do what I want and I do it for me, and before I know it, 2 and a half hours has flown by.
Now, this “noodle-ing” has its draw backs. I can often hear in my head some sense of what I want to play but my less than extensive experience with formal composition limits my ability to physically realize these vague ideas. I’ll have a sense of where a phrase wants to go, but won’t have the skill to make it happen. My pallet of compositional progressions, tricks and techniques are limited to what I have slowly discovered on my own over 12 years of incessant “noodle-ing” (I’ve driven my parents nuts on more than one occasion). New ideas almost always happen by accident and when they do I’ll be lucky if I can catch them in the moment and remember them.
I realize a lot of people compose this way and certainly I find it satisfying most of the time, especially since most of the time I’m not playing to write anything specific but rather just to play. Remember, there are no rules or goals in noodle-ing. However, it can be extremely frustrating, particularly in those moments when I do want to find something new and branch out from my usual bag of tricks but can’t figure out how to do it. It’s times like those that I wish I had a more thorough command of theory to fall back on. Of course that’s always something I can work on. I can always study up and practice more theory, but that would then be turning into work what I’ve deliberately reserved for fun.
At least I can lock myself in little practice rooms now and not drive my family and friends nuts with endless noodle-ing.