I have been taking a choral arrangement course this term from Jeff Smallman and it has to be one of the best courses I have ever taken. It’s been a blast writing arrangements and really applying my composition in a more formal way.
However, as fun as it has been, the final term project nearly killed me. We were assigned to combine the total sum of our skills learned in the class into one final choral piece. The only guidelines: write an SATB choral piece using a public domain text and/or melody with piano accompaniment.
I don’t think I have ever put so much time and effort into a university project before. I used nearly every single day of the two weeks given and it was a great experience, but also incredibly frustrating and exhausting.
I knew I wanted to write an original work and didn’t want to do an arrangement of an existing piece. So the first thing I had to do was find a text. I’m not very good with poetry and there are thousands of poets who have put sublime inspiration into words far better than I ever could. One such poet is Christina Rossetti (1830-1894). Her writing has the ability to touch me. Her poems make me cry. I figured if a text could do that, then it would stand up well to choral arrangement. I finally decided on “Song”
I set to work writing and things seemed to flow almost as well as the text, but then the nit-picking stage began, and I nearly lost my mind. See, I was working with a combination of notation software and the piano. Anyone who’s worked with notation software knows that it lies. The sounds you hear don’t necessarily reflect what a performance will sound like. More often than not what sounds awful on the computer will work wonderfully in performance. I found myself writing and re-writing lines over and over and adjusting harmonies and second guessing myself because what I was hearing from my computer and what I was hearing on the piano were different and I didn’t know which to trust more. Also, I have little experience writing piano accompaniments. Oh sure I write things on the piano all the time, but I’ve never written the piano as a background instrument. I must have written at least 3 new accompaniment parts. Each time I would write something and think “oh, yes, this works, this is great.” but as soon as I started piecing everything together I’d realize it didn’t work. I would have to scrap that whole thing and start over. You see, I struggle with keeping things simple. When I play around on the piano and really get into it, my instinct is to make it bigger and bigger to the point where I’m just rockin’ out. Now, this is fine if I am just fooling around and having fun. But for this text with this piece, big DOES NOT WORK. So it was a constant struggle to keep myself from getting carried away. I would have to remind myself to just keep it simple. I put hours and hours every day into this piece, so that I could get it just perfect. I got down right obsessive.
This choral arranging course has something of a history to it. There have been students who have written final term projects that turned out to be national competition winning pieces. There have been students who have had their term project published. Sarah Quartel wrote the 1st movement of her “Snow Angel”, one of the most moving and incredible contemporary choral works ever, in this course. Now I am by no means expecting this to happen to me but it does set a certain president and mood for what is possible.
I think I am fairly satisfied with my final product. After talking with my good friend Josh (a wicked saxophone player), I decided to include a soprano sax obbligato line which lends itself very well to the mood of the piece. There is certainly more I wish I could do with the piece. There are sections where I wanted to use certain techniques, but after days of trying I was unable to come up with anything particularly successful. May I’ll keep trying.
The project has been handed in, and we are now reading through our arrangements in class, which is so helped. It gives us the change to actually hear our pieces and discover what works and what doesn’t. My piece will be read on Thursday March 26th and I can hardly wait to get a sense of what it will sound like with a choir and real instruments.